Nucleic Acid Innovations to Manage Pathogen Sequence Divergence - Nucleic Acid Innovations to Manage Pathogen Sequence Divergence
Foundation for Applied Molecular Evolution
Steven A. Benner
Zunyi Yang
ABSTRACT
One of the most important outcomes from synthetic biology has been the recognition that many limitations
of diagnostics tools that target the DNA and RNA (collectively xNA) arise from defects in the xNA molecular
framework. These defects can be fixed by changing the structure of DNA used in these assays. The Benner lab
has created over a dozen reagent, enzyme, and architecture innovations based on this recognition. These are
now allowing assays to move from the clinical lab to emergency rooms to physicians offices.
In this progression, one problem arising from the molecular biology of the RNA viruses has remained recalci-
trant. The sequences of RNA viral genomes diverge rapidly. Thus, we do not know the exact sequence of the
xNA molecules that we are trying to detect in any patient. With increasing frequency, this allows RNA viruses
to escape primers and probes needed to detect their xNA. This, in turn, renders simple tests unable to detect a
virus with certainty. When these are intended to diagnose individual patients, this all but prevents FDA
approval under anything but emergency use authorizations. Further, this uncertainty in the target xNA makes
medically informative variation difficult to detect amid the medically uninformative variation.
This work will introduce NextGen “biversal” nucleic acid innovations to manage this problem. We begin with
by noting that viral sequence divergence occurs under strong adaptive constraints with error biases intrinsic in
relevant polymerases. Thus, transitions (purines replace purines, pyrimidines replace pyrimidines) are more
common than transversions (purines replace pyrimidines, or vice versa). This means that we can manage viral
genome divergence with pyrimidine biversals (Y) that pair to both A and G, and purine biversals (R) that pair
to both C and T. Biversals have advantages over “universal bases”, which create primers so promiscuous that
they get lost by binding to background xNA, abundant in real biological samples. These facts set up these aims.
Aim 1. Add NextGen biversals to isothermal amplification architectures, which allow diagnostics kits to move
closer to points-of-sampling and points-of-care. We will benchmark their performance relative to the
performance of amplifications with all-standard primers, and quantiate specificity footprints.
Aim 2. Characterize the details of how polymerases handle NextGen biversals, specifically, what standard
nucleotides are placed opposite these biversals by polymerases used in low-temperature amplifications.
Aim 3. Integrate NextGen biversals into architectures for SNP detection that exploit ligation and cleavage.
Rich preliminary data allow this project to move directly to a "development" stage. The emergence of Zika,
Ebola, chikungunya, dengue, and other RNA viral pathogens, and the soon-to-emerge Mayoro virus, points to
the immediate significance of this project. Especially innovative in this project is its integrated investigation of
alternative molecular structures, the enzymes called upon to handle them, and the architectures where they will
be used. These will allow FDA approvable diagnostics products to move towards points of sampling.